Wednesday, February 6, 2008
Rushing to Judgment
Well John McCain seems well on his way to winning the Republican nomination, and this has "conservative" talk show host Rush Limbaugh a little upset. It seems some people think John McCain has the best chance at beating Hillary Clinton. Mr. Limbaugh seems rather perplexed by this strategy; he does not seem to think there is much difference between Senators McCain and Clinton. And I suppose this means that for once there is something that Mr. Limbaugh and I agree on.
Friday, January 18, 2008
E.T. Phone Dawkins?
Following up on last week's article, I visited Prof. Dawkins website. I found it interesting that he has a link to the SETI Institute, yet I could find no links to organizations investigating the possibility of large aquatic reptiles in the water ways of Scotland, nor any to those looking into the possibility of diminutive aerial humanoids. Does Prof. Dawkins have some evidence of E.T. that I am not aware of? if so I would like to know what it is.
NOTE: God is technically an extra terrestrial intelligence (although He is also extra cosmic as well), so you could say that technically SETI is looking for God, but I wonder what they would do if they found Him?
NOTE: God is technically an extra terrestrial intelligence (although He is also extra cosmic as well), so you could say that technically SETI is looking for God, but I wonder what they would do if they found Him?
Friday, January 11, 2008
If You Say So
Have I nothing better to do than point out all the nonsense Professor Dawkins has to say when ever he gets on the telly? Well yes, actually I do. But if Dawkins insists on getting on the telly and saying it then I suppose I should do my part and point out that it is largely nonsense.
Recently Professor Dawkins was on a programme called "Have your say". The programme of course featured the usual suspects, things like who kills more people, theists or atheist, and other such drivel no thinking person cares about. Then of course Prof. Dawkins has to go through his rigmarole, comparing God to fairies and the lock ness monster because one cannot prove they do not exists, but there is no positive evidence that they do. Some might consider this a straw man, but I do not think such a comparison is even relevant enough for that. However Prof. Dawkins did say something interesting at the end. He said that he thinks the question of whether or not God exists is "very important". Does he consider the question of whether Nessy or Tinkerbell exists equally "important"?
Recently Professor Dawkins was on a programme called "Have your say". The programme of course featured the usual suspects, things like who kills more people, theists or atheist, and other such drivel no thinking person cares about. Then of course Prof. Dawkins has to go through his rigmarole, comparing God to fairies and the lock ness monster because one cannot prove they do not exists, but there is no positive evidence that they do. Some might consider this a straw man, but I do not think such a comparison is even relevant enough for that. However Prof. Dawkins did say something interesting at the end. He said that he thinks the question of whether or not God exists is "very important". Does he consider the question of whether Nessy or Tinkerbell exists equally "important"?
Wednesday, January 2, 2008
Princess Chastity and the Horny Toad.
Princess Chastity glided gracefully across the prairie her long red hair flowed behind her like a brilliant flame caught in the wind. Her sparkling blue green eyes seemed to flirt both with the bright sky above as well as the lush grass beneath her dainty feet, and her fair skin glowed with delight to show the morning sun, whose rays had decorated her with delicate freckles, the exquisite art more lovely than any wrought with mortal hands.
Presently she came upon a horny toad.
"Hay, how’s about giving us a kiss?" said the Horny Toad.
"Oh, are you a noble prince who has been placed under a transmorphic spell by an evil sorceress?" ask Princess Chastity.
"What’s that got to do with it?" replied the Horny Toad, "Look, are you going to kiss me, or do I have to find another beautiful princess?"
"But there are no other beautiful princesses in this story." said Princess Chastity.
"Like there are an abundance of other horny toads?" said the Horny Toad, "now how’s about less jawing and more kissing."
"But it is not very pleasant to kiss a horny toad." objected Princess Chastity.
"And I suppose you think it is some great fun to kiss a knobble prince?" said the Horny Toad, "Look sweetheart, the fact is you are going to have the lion’s share of the cuteness no matter who your kissy partner is. So your best bet is to just use him as a means to vicariously enjoy your own beauty, and I can assure you I'll enjoy you at least as much as any old stinking noble prince."
And so it was that Princess Chastity kissed the horny toad and they lived happily ever after.
THE END
Presently she came upon a horny toad.
"Hay, how’s about giving us a kiss?" said the Horny Toad.
"Oh, are you a noble prince who has been placed under a transmorphic spell by an evil sorceress?" ask Princess Chastity.
"What’s that got to do with it?" replied the Horny Toad, "Look, are you going to kiss me, or do I have to find another beautiful princess?"
"But there are no other beautiful princesses in this story." said Princess Chastity.
"Like there are an abundance of other horny toads?" said the Horny Toad, "now how’s about less jawing and more kissing."
"But it is not very pleasant to kiss a horny toad." objected Princess Chastity.
"And I suppose you think it is some great fun to kiss a knobble prince?" said the Horny Toad, "Look sweetheart, the fact is you are going to have the lion’s share of the cuteness no matter who your kissy partner is. So your best bet is to just use him as a means to vicariously enjoy your own beauty, and I can assure you I'll enjoy you at least as much as any old stinking noble prince."
And so it was that Princess Chastity kissed the horny toad and they lived happily ever after.
THE END
Wednesday, December 26, 2007
Exercising Demons
I had concluded not to see the Golden Compass movie, but then a small mouse in my study reasoned with me thus, saying "being as you are a virgin mind in this matter, never having been sullied by the books, you are in a special position to evaluate the movie as a movie." And so it was that I went to see the film, and after doing so I said unto the mouse, "Get real; you are supposed to be my demon? My demon is a twelve ton dragon that can slay armed hosts just by farting." "Yes" replied the mouse, "but conceptually that would not fit inside your study now would it?"
Frances Schaffer once said "An artist's creativity shows his world view, his world view almost always shows through." Philip Pullman however has all but stated that his art is merely a vehicle for his world view. However, my purpose here is not to critique Philip Pullman's world view, I am not even critiquing his book, I am critiquing a film based on his book and I shall try to evaluate it purely on its own artistic merits.
SFX
The special effects are impressive, which is a problem. You see if you are paying more attention to the special effects then the story they are supposedly telling then something is amiss. For example, the polar bears were extremely well rendered very realistic digital polar bears, and that is exactly what I was thinking every time they were on screen, oh and the fact that the king polar bear apparently likes to play with dolls does not help the suspension of disbelief any. Also the view from the air ship's observation room was quite memorable, which is more then I can say for any of the dialoged that was spoken there. And so I have to give the movie high marks for technically good special effects but they were special effects that replaced the story rather than told it.
CAST
Dakota Blue Richards as Lyra is fairly good, at least she is pretty enough to look at for two hours and she avoids hamming and seems to know how to curtsy. As far as her realization of the character goes, that is a bit more difficult to analyze. This is not a "classical" scenario of a girl and her polymorphic, talking pet going on an adventure. The bond they share is deeper and more mysterious, yet at times this is not very apparent. Whether Richards has sorted it all out in her own mind is not clear, but at least her confidence keeps there from being any real problems. As for the rest of the cast, they are adequate though largely irrelevant. Though I would like to give Christopher Lee and Sir Derek George Jacobi an honorable mention, the problem is that they were ask to sell a moral wait and expositional gravity that the script had not actually given them.
THE STORY
I must say that I find the "demons" (interdependent incarnate spirits dwelling alongside each humanoid) as a literary device, intriguing. The fact that children have polymorphic demons suggests even more possibilities. Unfortunately the story that is being told here generally reduces the demons to mere sidekicks, or more often just character traits that fade into the background shortly after being introduced. The plot that seems to emerge is the idea that children are being kidnapped so that their polymorphic demons can be harvested for some nefarious purpose apparently involving spice (the spice is the worm the worm is the spice) sorry I meant dust of course. I say "the idea" because one is largely left trying to peace to gather what it is all really about and there seem to be a few peaces missing. There are some vague indications that the sequels have these missing peaces, but this is hardly satisfactory, if NL is thinking LOTR here, I have to say there is a big difference, delayed resolution is one thing, delayed explanation is quite another.
Tuesday, December 18, 2007
Reactionary Weekly indorses Tom Tancredo for US president!
What? You were expecting maybe John Edwards?
Wednesday, December 12, 2007
Silly Grownups
“Children have one kind of silliness, as you know, and grownups have another kind.” – C.S. Lewis
A while back I said something to the effect that I was sure Professor Dawkins could tell us all sorts of fascinating things about amino acids and helixes and chromosomes, and not come anywhere near all the nonsense he becomes entangled in when he talks about God.
Well I am afraid that after watching his lecture series Growing Up in the Universe, I must say I may have been mistaken. First though let me say that when it comes to telling us things about biology and ethology, he is really rather good. But he just cannot seem to keep from straying into more philosphic matters. At the end of the lecturs he saluts our ponderusly larg brains and proclams that at last there is a truly “grownup” specis in the unavers.
Now, I may be wrong, but is this not exactly the sort of conceit that he warns us against in The Ancestor's Tale? Is not the wasp “grownup” compared to the bacteria? Might we not be infantile compared to some other being?
The Ancestor's Tale, was apparently written well after the “growing up” lectures, perhaps Professor Dawkins’ worldview is evolving.
A while back I said something to the effect that I was sure Professor Dawkins could tell us all sorts of fascinating things about amino acids and helixes and chromosomes, and not come anywhere near all the nonsense he becomes entangled in when he talks about God.
Well I am afraid that after watching his lecture series Growing Up in the Universe, I must say I may have been mistaken. First though let me say that when it comes to telling us things about biology and ethology, he is really rather good. But he just cannot seem to keep from straying into more philosphic matters. At the end of the lecturs he saluts our ponderusly larg brains and proclams that at last there is a truly “grownup” specis in the unavers.
Now, I may be wrong, but is this not exactly the sort of conceit that he warns us against in The Ancestor's Tale? Is not the wasp “grownup” compared to the bacteria? Might we not be infantile compared to some other being?
The Ancestor's Tale, was apparently written well after the “growing up” lectures, perhaps Professor Dawkins’ worldview is evolving.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)